5 Things you didn’t know drive Instagram Story engagement
Instagram Stories are one of the most powerful tools on the app for building real connection with your audience. But if your views are low or your replies are non-existent, you’re not alone. The good news? There are some seriously underrated tactics you can use to get more people tapping, reacting, and engaging with your content — without burning yourself out.
Here are five things you might not realise are secretly boosting (or tanking) your Instagram Story engagement — and how to use them to your advantage.
1. Posting at the Wrong Times
Timing matters more than you think. If you’re posting Stories when your audience isn’t online, they might never see them — especially if other accounts push you further down the queue.
Hot tip: Check your Instagram Insights to find your followers’ most active hours. Post during those windows to stay at the front of the line. If you have a global audience, try spacing out Stories across the day.
2. Not Using Engagement Stickers
Polls, quizzes, sliders, questions; these aren’t just fun add-ons. Instagram literally favours content that encourages interaction. More taps and replies = more reach.
Hot tip: Add one interactive sticker to every few Stories. Even a simple emoji slider can tell the algorithm that people are engaging. Want to double your chances? Ask easy questions that require no effort to answer.
3. Skipping the Behind-the-Scenes Content
Polished graphics are nice, but people crave real. Behind-the-scenes moments, process clips, voiceovers, and casual check-ins help your audience feel more connected to you.
Hot tip: Share your workspace, a messy middle moment, or a “here’s what I’m working on” Story. Even just talking to camera for 15 seconds can do more than 10 Canva graphics.
4. Too Many Stories at Once
Ever tapped through a Story that looked more like a mini film? People drop off fast if they feel overwhelmed. Story fatigue is real, and the more you post in one go, the less likely people are to stay with you until the end.
Hot tip: Aim for 3–5 slides at a time, max. Break up your content across the day instead of dumping it all at once. More chances for visibility, less risk of drop-offs.
5. Ignoring Captions and Accessibility
A silent Story is a missed opportunity. Most people watch Stories with sound off — and if they can’t understand what’s happening, they’ll swipe.
Hot tip: Use Instagram’s built-in captions or add your own text. Make sure your font is legible and contrast is high. Bonus points for using ALT text when you can.
Final Thoughts: Consistency Beats Perfection
Instagram Story engagement isn’t just about flashy design or shouting louder. It’s about showing up in ways that feel natural and human, and making it easy for your audience to connect with you.
Want to make your Instagram Stories work harder for your brand? Try these tips for a week and track your views and interactions. Little changes = big difference.
Need Help With Your Instagram Strategy?
If you're stuck in a Story slump, don’t stress. I work with small business owners and creatives to turn their content into something people actually want to engage with.
Book a free strategy call and let’s get your content back on track.